83 From Critics, 2.3 From Players: Why Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Is Getting Crushed on Metacritic

Oatchi swimming with Ice Pikmin in Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition

Launched on November 12, 2026 for $59.99 / €69.99 as a standalone package (or as a $9.99 / £7.99 / €9.99 paid upgrade pack for owners of the July 2023 release), Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy is facing intense community backlash. While professional critics awarded the re-release a favorable 83 Metascore, the player rating has plunged to a 2.3 out of 10 user score on the official Pikmin 4: Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Metacritic page, placing it firmly in the "Generally Unfavorable" tier.

Trailer video

Loading Times Balloon From 6 Seconds to 30 Seconds Beside a Locked 30 FPS Cap

At the center of the negative user reviews is an unexpected technical regression on Nintendo's newer hardware. Throughout the main story campaign, transition screens when entering or exiting underground caves and loading surface exploration zones now stretch to 30 seconds or longer on the Nintendo Switch 2 Edition, compared to roughly 6 seconds on the original 2023 Nintendo Switch version.

According to player testing shared across community threads, the slowdown is most severe when running the game from a physical game card, though digital eShop installations also load noticeably slower than the original release. Transferring the installation data from a microSD Express card directly to the console's internal system storage offers only minor relief without fixing the underlying bottleneck. Adding to the technical frustration, although the upgrade boosts visual output to native 4K resolution in docked TV mode and 1080p in handheld mode, the framerate remains strictly capped at 30 frames per second (30 FPS) with no 60 FPS performance mode available.

Recycled Maps and a 12-Month Drip-Feed Schedule in Dandori Academy

Beyond performance complaints, players are questioning the value proposition of the $9.99 upgrade pack. Shortly after the title appeared in the November 15 Nintendo eShop best-seller charts, returning fans dug into Dandori Academy, the new time-attack challenge mode overseen by the Sage Leaf.

As detailed in our breakdown of how the 72 challenges in Pikmin 4's Dandori Academy schedule operate, only 6 stages are unlocked at launch, with the remaining courses distributed in batches of six on the first Monday of each month over a full year alongside weekend-only ranked exams from Friday to Sunday. More importantly, user reviews heavily criticize the expansion for recycling map geometry and cave layouts directly from the 2023 base campaign rather than delivering freshly built arenas.

Underground cave boss fight in Pikmin 4 on Nintendo Switch 2 with Oatchi
Underground cave transitions in the main story campaign have become a major flashpoint for players timing 30-second loading screens on Switch 2.

Other platform-specific additions, including single-copy two-player sharing for Dandori Battles via GameShare and GameChat as well as 9 microphone voice commands to issue direct orders to the rescue pup Oatchi, have largely been dismissed by reviewers as minor novelties. For many existing owners, paying ten dollars for an update that lengthens base-game loading screens while keeping the 30 FPS ceiling feels like a step backward.

Check Availability on Amazon→

My Field Notes

User score pile-ons on Metacritic can sometimes blow minor gripes out of proportion, but the frustration aimed at this Switch 2 upgrade is rooted in measurable technical regressions. Charging $9.99 only for cave loading screens to jump from 6 seconds to 30 seconds while leaving the framerate locked at 30 FPS undercuts the entire point of a next-generation hardware patch. Until Nintendo rolls out a patch that restores loading speeds to at least match the 2023 cartridge, returning players are better off holding onto their ten dollars.

Follow Pro-Gamer on Discord
Get instant gaming news, hardware price alerts, and vote on new releases live with the community.
Join the Discord →
Bastien "Orion"
Written by Bastien "Orion"
🌎 Gaming News & Culture Writer ⚜️ Quebec City

Originally from Lyon, France, gaming journalist Bastien "Orion" relocated nearly a decade ago to Quebec City's Saint-Roch district, right in the heart of eastern Canada's development studio hub. Before crossing the Atlantic, he honed his versatile reporting style across classic French gaming web portals and specialist television outlets in the 2000s and 2010s, notably with JeuxVideo.fr and JeuxNews. Equally passionate about AAA blockbusters, North American studio culture, retro preservation, and community modding projects, he anchors Pro-Gamer's transatlantic desk and real-time coverage of US and Japanese industry announcements.

Focus: 🌎 North America Desk, AAA & Preservation @JeuxNewscom @orion.pg
All articles by Bastien →

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.