GTA 6 Guide: Should You Kill or Spare Arnold in Hey Arnold for the $10,000 Reward?

Jason Duval holding Arnold at gunpoint on the dock during the Hey Arnold mission in GTA 6

Direct Answer: You should spare Arnold at the end of the "Hey Arnold!" main story mission in Chapter 1 of Grand Theft Auto VI. Letting Brian Heder's broker live shifts Jason Duval's Criminal Profile toward the Restrained rating and unlocks a $10,000 cash bonus later in Chapter 4 after Brian and Arnold patch things up. On the other hand, executing Arnold on the pier yields zero extra loot right away and pushes your morality gauge heavily toward the Hardened Criminal rating.

As the very first major moral dilemma in the main campaign, this binary choice takes place at the end of the tenth chronological story mission in the Leonida Keys, right after completing Pipework and dealing with the Kingfishers. Because story missions cannot be replayed on the fly while your campaign is in progress, the decision you make on the Maroon Key dock is permanent for your active save file.

Kill vs. Spare Arnold Comparison Table (Plus the Hidden Third Option)

Unlike traditional RPGs, Rockstar Games does not freeze the screen with a paused dialogue wheel. Jason holds Arnold at gunpoint at the end of the wooden pier, and what you do with your firearm determines the outcome, including a secret third resolution if you simply stand still and refuse to pull the trigger.

Choice on the PierJason Duval's ActionCriminal Profile ImpactLong-Term Story & Cash Consequence (Chapter 4)
Spare Arnold (Recommended)Jason lowers his pistol and warns Arnold never to talk before letting him go.Restrained rating: keeps Jason's behavioral profile clean and professional.Arnold dives into the water and swims away. In Chapter 4, he reconciles with Brian Heder and sends you a $10,000 bonus as a thank-you gift.
Kill ArnoldJason pulls the trigger and executes Arnold on his knees at the end of the dock.Hardened Criminal rating: triggers an immediate warning about indiscriminate violence.Arnold is dead for good. You get no extra cash from his body and permanently miss out on the $10,000 reward in Chapter 4.
Do Nothing (Hidden Idle Option)Stand still for several seconds aiming at Arnold without shooting or lowering your weapon.Restrained rating: the game counts inaction identically to actively sparing him.Arnold says he will take his chances swimming, jumps off the dock, and escapes. You still receive the $10,000 bonus in Chapter 4.

Step-by-Step Walkthrough for the "Hey Arnold!" Mission in Chapter 1

Before you reach the final standoff on the dock, you need to track down Arnold, the middleman behind Donnie's drug runs who suddenly stopped answering Brian Heder's phone calls. Follow these five steps to clear the ambush and reach the choice quickly:

Brian Heder confronting Arnold outside the Maroon Key radar station in GTA 6
Brian Heder confronting his broker Arnold outside the Maroon Key radar station before the shootout erupts.
  1. Meet Brian Heder in Southern Key Lento: Shortly after finishing Pipework, Brian calls Jason and asks to meet at the Crastenburg pool bar in southern Key Lento. Speak with him by the bar, walk out to his pickup truck, and get into the driver's seat.
  2. Pick Up Cal Hampton at the Liquor Store: Drive Brian to the nearby liquor store and wait for Cal to hop in. Cal traces Arnold's cell phone signal while you head south down the Keys causeway.
  3. Find Arnold at the Maroon Key Radar Station: Drive toward the large white aerostat blimp floating above Maroon Key. Once the yellow search zone narrows into an exact waypoint, take the first road on the left to find Arnold and his crew outside a small utility building near the radar station.
  4. Survive the High-Speed Truck Chase Against the Bikers: Arnold tells Brian their business is finished and speeds off in his car while his henchmen open fire. Stay close behind him in Brian's truck, use slow-motion drive-by aiming to take down the motorcycle gunmen, and hit the bridge ramp stunt jumps along the route.
  5. Chase Arnold on Foot to the End of the Pier: Once Arnold abandons his vehicle, sprint after him through the residential yards. Hold the camera lock-on prompt to keep him centered around tight corners until he is trapped on his knees at the end of a wooden dock.
Chasing Arnold and his motorcycle gunmen in Brian's pickup truck in GTA 6
Pursuing Arnold's getaway car and his motorcycle gunmen down the Maroon Key causeway in Brian's pickup truck.

What Happens If You Spare Arnold (How to Get the $10,000 Bonus)

Cornered at the edge of the pier, Arnold begs for mercy and explains that he wants to leave the criminal underworld behind and disappear for good. If you choose to Spare Arnold (or simply wait without firing), Jason warns him to keep his mouth shut, prompting Arnold to dive straight into the ocean and swim away.

Arnold swimming away from the dock after Jason spares his life in GTA 6
Arnold swimming away into the ocean after Jason lowers his gun and spares his life on the Maroon Key dock.

When you return to Brian Heder, Jason tells him that Arnold will not cause any further trouble, which satisfies Brian completely. The real payoff arrives much later in the story: during Chapter 4, Brian contacts you to mention that he bumped into Arnold and that the two are back on good terms. Arnold then wires you a $10,000 cash bonus in gratitude for sparing his life back in the Keys. Combined with the methods in our complete GTA 6 money farming guide to make cash fast in every chapter, this free payout is an effortless boost to your mid-game bank account.

What Happens If You Kill Arnold on the Dock?

If you pull the trigger and execute Arnold while he is kneeling unarmed on the pier, the game immediately displays a system notification warning that indiscriminate violence pushes your Criminal Profile toward a more violent rating. Grand Theft Auto VI tracks how ruthlessly Jason and Lucia handle surrendering targets, and cold-blooded executions shift your profile toward Hardened Criminal, which ties into how law enforcement responds to your escalation alongside the mechanics covered in our GTA 6 wanted levels and Heat system guide.

Aside from the morality shift and losing the $10,000 Chapter 4 payout, killing Arnold does not fail any mission objective or lock you out of future storylines. Regardless of whether Arnold lives or dies, the mission concludes back at Brian Heder's house, where you are introduced to his treasure-hunting friend Kenton (unlocking underwater diving jobs in the Keys) while Brian drops your base mission pay into Jason's mailbox.

Official Game Hub 19 novembre 2026

Grand Theft Auto 6 (GTA 6)

Explore official trailers, technical specs and all latest coverage for Grand Theft Auto 6 (GTA 6).

PlayStation 5 Xbox Series X|S PC
Follow Pro-Gamer on Discord
Get instant gaming news, hardware price alerts, and vote on new releases live with the community.
Join the Discord →
Chaya "Chayane"
Written by Chaya "Chayane"
🧠 Deep Learning AI & Dev 🗽 New York & Montreal

Based on the outskirts of New York City, Chaya 'Chayane' spent five years studying software engineering in Montreal before returning to her home state. A Full-Stack developer and Deep Learning AI architecture researcher, she explores neural networks and algorithmic optimization while engineering data pipelines for Retrocharting and Gamescharting alongside Grimtag. A gamer for over 20 years and an avid collector of Nintendo history and The Legend of Zelda, she explored World of Warcraft's Azeroth before bringing her deep technical background to video game analysis.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.